Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, Volume III Hints

Who killed Melvin Tuttle?

  • 1 of 9: Tuttle gave his girlfriend some information on some seedy business deals.
  • 2 of 9: Both Swathmore and Livingston were searching through his locker at Bell's Baths to find that information.
  • 3 of 9: If you talked to H. R. Murray, you should know that Tuttle was poisoned.
  • 4 of 9: And if you did any research at the library, you should know about the poison that killed Tuttle.
  • 5 of 9: Chinaberry smells like lilac.
  • 6 of 9: Heathcliff received an envelope scented like lilac.
  • 7 of 9: And Henry Swathmore gave that envelope to Tuttle.
  • 8 of 9: So Swathmore is the murderer.
  • 9 of 9: The poison was put on the envolope (A).