Sherlock Holmes versus Arsene Lupin Hints

How can I determine which is Johnson's locker?

  • 1 of 18: This is an elaborate but sensical puzzle.
  • 2 of 18: You need to listen to all the clues you were given by the guards, including the one you spoke to -- all the clues found in the objects and documents in the dormitory, and any other information you can deduce. Use all of Sherlock's skill!
  • 3 of 18: Take the known facts first:
  • 4 of 18: The locker with moustache hair outside it, and the locker with green paint on it.
  • 5 of 18: These match the features of two of the guards we met outside, Shick and Kirkpatrick.
  • 6 of 18: So, place Shick at Locker 6, and Kirkpatrick at Locker 12 -- we are certain of those two facts.
  • 7 of 18: Now continue to extrapolate truths from the remaining information you have.
  • 8 of 18: The guard outside the cloakroom will give you additional hints before Lupin's sleeping pill knocks him out.
  • 9 of 18: He will tell you that Flint's locker is at the back of the room -- furthest from the door.
  • 10 of 18: He will also tell you that his locker is inbetween those of Bell, and the new warder.
  • 11 of 18: It's also possible to work out who the new warder is -- he left a clue in the dormitory.
  • 12 of 18: There is a letter on a table there from an R. Moore, and by reading it you can determine that Moore is the new worker.
  • 13 of 18: So we know that Hickman belongs between Bell and Moore.
  • 14 of 18: He also tells you that the short guard is Jones.
  • 15 of 18: The stepping stool outside locker 16 thus proves that this is Jones' locker.
  • 16 of 18: With these pieces of information you should be able to place all the other guards -- just remember that Moore, Hickman, and Bell need three adjacent lockers, and that Willoughby is closer to the entrance than any of the three of them, on the same side.
  • 17 of 18: The order of the lockers is shown below:
  • 18 of 18: 1: O'Shea
    2: Willoughby
    3: Moore
    4: Hickman
    5: Bell
    6: Shick
    7: Johnson
    8: Summerbee
    9: Flint
    10: Ludlow
    11: March
    12: Kirkpatrick
    13: Stiles
    14: Mortensen
    15: Law
    16: Jones